Friday, February 4, 2011

Are you a sheep or a sheepdog?

By Shannon

Dave Grossman has a theory about wolves, sheep, and sheepdogs.  It is well worth reading the entire theory here.

The majority of people are sheep.  They are kind, decent people who do not hurt each other except by accident.  In Personal Responsibility Matters I told you that 80% of crimes are committed by 0.3% of the population.  In 2009 approximately 3% of the population were victims of some sort of crime.  This tends to prove the point that most people are kind and decent.  It also shows that crime is still somewhat rare. 


However, crime does exist and the wolves feed on the sheep without mercy.  Wolves have capacities for violence and no empathy for their fellow man.

The sheepdogs on the other hand, live to protect the sheep and confront the wolf.  Sheepdogs have capacities for violence like the wolf, but sheepdogs also have a deep love for their fellow man. 


The relationship between the sheep and sheepdogs is best described by Grossman:

“The sheep generally do not like the sheepdog. He looks a lot like the wolf. He has fangs and the capacity for violence. The difference, though, is that the sheepdog must not, can not and will not ever harm the sheep. Any sheepdog who intentionally harms the lowliest little lamb will be punished and removed [by the other sheepdogs]. The world cannot work any other way, at least not in a representative democracy or a republic such as ours. Still, the sheepdog disturbs the sheep. He is a constant reminder that there are wolves in the land. They would prefer that he didn't tell them where to go, or give them traffic tickets, or stand at the ready in our airports in camouflage fatigues holding an M-16. The sheep would much rather have the sheepdog cash in his fangs, spray paint himself white, and go, "Baa." ---Until the wolf shows up. Then the entire flock tries desperately to hide behind one lonely sheepdog.  Understand that there is nothing morally superior about being a sheepdog; it is just what you choose to be. Also understand that a sheepdog is a funny critter: He is always sniffing around out on the perimeter, checking the breeze, barking at things that go bump in the night, and yearning for a righteous battle.  Here is how the sheep and the sheepdog think differently. The sheep pretend the wolf will never come, but the sheepdog lives for that day.”

Reading the coverage of the shooting in Tuscon, I marveled.  Once upon a time, America cowered in crisis and waited for first responders.  However, post 9/11 many of us (including white-haired ladies) have become first responders.  More of us choose to be sheepdogs to protect one another in the moment of crisis.  That makes me proud of my nation.

Grossman says that a sheepdog is “someone who can walk into the heart of darkness, into the universal human phobia, and walk out unscathed.”  As a sheepdog, I disagree with him on this point.  Police, soldiers, prosecutors, and all those who look evil in the eye and say, “This far - no farther,”  we are not invincible.  We have flashbacks, fears, and PTSD.  We walk into the heart of darkness, not because we cannot be scathed, but because it is worth the scathing effect.  It is worth it when I get to tell a child that the jury believed her and her stepfather cannot ever rape her again.  It is worth it when I send a psychopath to prison so that he cannot hurt any sheep for awhile.  It’s worth it and yet I cannot seem to forget Nietzche’s warning:  “He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster. And if you gaze for long into an abyss, the abyss gazes also into you.”

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Zombies in The Law By Ann

      Heart racing, palms sweating, and stomach retching, she walks.  She carries her 5’5 frame and follows an armed guard through a dark, cold, and wet cavern. To a cell inhabited by a six feet tall zombie, chained by his neck with his mouth dripping with someone else's blood, she walks.  When she gets there, he growls and spits and runs as fast as he can towards her.  Luckily, every time he gets within inches, the chain pulls him back and he slams into the wall.  The guard locks her in the room and she sits. 


To be fair, I have explored some challenges public defenders face such as antagonistic cops, the heartless prosecutor, and the good defendant in Methusalah Goes To Court.  Today I introduce you to the client who believes, like many, that public defenders are incompetent, inexperienced, secret agents for the prosecution. 
Hypothetically, when I go to court, the judge calls the list.  I stand as my client’s names are called.


Judge:  Ms. Defender do you represent the following defendants:
  1. Guy who got caught on To Catch A Predator with whiskey and condoms in his pocket claiming he  was only there to teach the kid what could happen if she talks to pervs on the internet?
  2. The woman aired on America’s Dumbest Criminals who robbed a video surveillance store and was clearly videotaped.
  3. The guy who engaged in a high speed chase through two counties and was stopped by hitting a school bus full of children in front of hundreds of witnesses.


Defender:  Yes, yes, and yes.

The judge gives me time to speak to my clients who call me names, accuse me of being incompetent and insult me mercilessly for the next hour. They have unrealistic expectations of what can be done and believe that by attacking their public defender, they will get those results. I have to explain to these defendants legal latin terms, criminal procedure, and their rights all in less than 60 minutes.  D
id you ever wonder what the  nuances,  the mannerisms, and the thought processes were of the first human like creature that emerged in evolution?

    I don’t.

www.ghoulfriday.com
She sits and tries to ignore his grunts and screams.  Once he has exhausted himself, and stands there drooling with empty eyes….she begins.  “Well Mr. Zombie, it looks like you’re charged with Consuming a Living Person, but I believe there may be a double jeopardy issue...”  
He sighs heavily and her hair blows back covered and moved by his putrid breath, still hot from eating his last victim.  She wants to run but she stands her ground.   
Her job, her values, her constitution, they are all bigger than this guy. 

WINNER!

The winner of the $20 gift certificate giveaway is:

DRUMROLL PLEASE...


TRISHA HOOVER!

Trisha, please email us at twoangelsofjustice@gmail.com to claim your gift certificate!

Everyone else, please keep reading... more giveaways are coming!!!

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Certain Unalienable Rights

By Shannon

I know I’m supposed to be writing about technicalities in the criminal justice system, but if you don’t mind there’s something more pressing on my mind today. 

First, let me say in response to Ann’s moving (seriously her stories made my eyes tear up!) post from yesterday that prosecutors (most of us) venerate the Constitution.  It should be the highest goal of every lawyer, every politician, and every citizen to not only adhere to and honor the ideals set forth in that magnificent document, but to hold our representatives, officers, and lawyers feet to the fire if they dare ignore or dismiss the Constitution.  I am lucky.  My first job as a prosecutor was for a DA who had been a defense attorney for many years and still thought as a defense attorney.  I then went out on my own for a bit as a defense attorney and that has served me well in my return to prosecution.  I am much more sensitive to and careful with the rights of each defendant.  I now work for a DA who is a man of integrity.  He’s so ethical that when an officer is fired for dishonesty their cases are dismissed.  PERIOD.  Even if the officer is fired for lying about something that has nothing to do with a case, my boss dismisses his cases.  If an officer will lie about something insignificant, won’t they lie about something significant?  Most cops I know prize honesty and protect their reputation by making integrity a priority.  When an officer fails to do so, he needs to find something else to do.  If a prosecutor is willing to win AT ALL COSTS, they need to find something else to do because JUSTICE is all that matters.

Second, let me say that I am shaking with anger as I write to you today.  Today the subject of the Egyptian riots came up while we were visiting during court.  I told a group of attorneys that for the first time I understand that America has been known to get into bed with despots for the sake “stability” – the people of that nation be damned.  It turns my stomach.  If we are truly “the land of the free and the home of the brave,” we MUST be brave enough to choose what is right NOT what is expedient.  I was told today that stability is important because it protects our interests.  I get that stability is expedient, but I believe we have more interest in protecting people.  There’s no excuse for helping put in office and/or financially supporting despots with a record of human rights violations including torture.  I was then told by several attorneys that “human rights” is a made-up thing that “does not exist in nature.”  In fact one told me that the “only law in nature is that the strong survive and make servants of the weak.”  Let’s examine that.

Our Founding Fathers were influenced by the Greek philosophers, Locke, Cicero, and others.  All of these including our Fathers believed in something called “Natural Law.” 

“True law [also called Natural law] is of universal application, unchanging and everlasting; it summons duty by its commands, and averts from wrongdoing by its prohibitions…. It is impossible to abolish it entirely.  There will not be different laws at Rome and at Athens, or different laws now and in the future, but one eternal and unchangeable law will be valid for all nations and all times….”  ~ Cicero

“The state of Nature has a law of Nature to govern it, which… teaches all mankind… no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty or possessions…. there cannot be supposed any such subordination among us that may authorize us to destroy one another.” ~ Locke


Natural Law is evident throughout our Declaration of Independence:
“When in the Course of human events it becomes necessary for one people… to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.  We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by the Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness."  Notice that there is no right to happiness itself, but there is a right to pursue happiness.

Not only do human rights exist, they are the foundation of our nation.  Even if “human rights” is a made up concept, isn’t it an ideal that we should strive for?  The world will never change – indeed cannot be changed – until we are willing to make the hard choices and stand up for what is right NOT what is expedient.  Don’t we all dream of a better world?  Don’t we at least dream of a better nation? 

I couldn’t understand how we’d gotten ourselves into a position that required our President to either side with a despot for the sake of stability or to ask an ally to step down for the sake of his people.  I am ashamed that any of our leaders ever chose what was expedient over what was right thereby putting today’s President in a position to have to choose between those two options.  

I may be idealistic in believing that we can change the world, but in the words of Robert Kennedy, “Some men see things as they are and ask why.  I dream things that never were and ask why not.”  I know I am not alone.  For the sake of humanity, choose what is right over what is expedient even if what is right is a harder road to travel and one that costs you more personally.  Demand your government do the same.

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

The Constitution is Not a Technicality


In Afghanistan, a young mother took hurried, successive, little steps on a dusty road on her way back from the market.  She was on her way home to cook dinner but was slightly concerned because her little boy ran ahead and she could barely see him.  He would throw a rock and chase it.  Throw and chase.  She would tell him to stay close but he would scamper ahead just as small children are prone to do.  He was about 100 yards away from her when the ministry of vice religious police saw her illegal transgression.  She was walking in the street unaccompanied by any male!
The white pick up truck with three religious officials drove by, screeched to a halt and backed up, almost hitting her in the process.  Before she could explain that her little boy was just up ahead, they got out grabbed the food out of her hands, threw it to the ground and beat her mercilessly.  She would live out her years walking with a limp as a painful reminder of that day.
This scenario, while fictional but based on real events, is the prime example of the evil spawned by an entity which ruthlessly and inhumanely polices the public without supervision, moderation, or a bill of rights.

We don’t do that here.  We don’t do that because we have a constitution that protects us from the whims of a tyrannical government.  We don’t do that here because we have fundamental rights that protect us.  We don't do that because the founding fathers created a document that ensured our civil liberties would be ensured. And it works. 
At least in theory.

For example, a man was suspected of stealing copper.  The police go to his home where he and his girlfriend are inside.  They are both taken down to the station in police cars (in the back seat) and put in separate rooms with locked doors and officers with guns.  The guy is under the influence of something and the girl is questioned mercilessly.  They are told they can leave but they are 8 miles from home in the middle of winter.  Eventually they grow bored with the girlfriend and drive her home.  The guy who is "free to leave" is handcuffed to a wooden bench for 10 hours.  He falls asleep and they splash his face with water until he wakes up.  This plays out several times. He does not get to eat and he does not get to go to the bathroom.  He does not get to go to sleep. He finally confesses and agrees to write it on paper. He would have done anything to go home.  Of course, I promptly filed a motion to suppress (ask the court to exclude the evidence because this is clearly a coerced confession and very illegal).  
The court ruled against my client and held that he was “free to leave” at any time and was not coerced!
 

“How can you sleep at night knowing you get criminals off on a technicality?”  I get asked this a lot and I don’t know how I would sleep at night because the reality is that it’s never happened.  A technicality implies that the prosecutor put the wrong date on a motion or misspelled the defendant’s name.  This is more of an urban legend than a reality. 
In the years that I have been practicing, I have had only two cases where the court actually looked at the facts and excluded evidence which was obtained illegally and told the prosecution they couldn’t use it.  That means that the police broke the law when they investigated my client.  When the police break the law, they aren’t allowed to use that evidence.  Of course, if you or I break the law, we go to jail.  But that will be explored in the next post where I explore some slimy government tactics.

There is no mass exodus of criminals being expelled from the prisons as a result of technicalities.  There are only occasional safeguards put into place to avoid illegal behavior by the police so that we are safe and free from tyranny.
www.gifs.net

Still not convinced?
That’s ok you’re in good company. Some countries don’t buy into our Bill of Rights either.  In fact, famous dictators such as Hitler, Saddam Hussein, Yasser Arafat, Papa Doc, and Kim Jong Il share the same sentiment and they never had to worry about any pesky technicalities.