By Shannon
I realize that for those who sit at the other table next to defense attorneys I am a threatening figure. I understand that defendants liken me to the anti-Christ. I get it. Each time I go to trial against someone I try to put myself in his family's shoes. I imagine believing my loved-one is innocent - or if not "innocent" per se, at least undeserving of justice because of mitigating circumstances. I know that they do not comprehend the lengths I go to in order to make sure I'm not trying an innocent person. I know they would not believe me if I told them how much compassion I truly feel for them and that for some of them I've even shed a few tears. I get all of that. However, I wish they understood that it is really stupid to attack and antagonize me during the process because their bad behavior has a tendency to mitigate any compassion I may have felt.
For instance, in this current trial I gave the opening statement on Tuesday. It's the only time I've spoken during this week of trial. My parts come later on. So, why did this family decide to mock me for being anemic after they heard me speaking to my doctor's office on the phone outside? Really? I didn't know anemia was such a hot-button topic! They also heckled me in the courtroom because an overzealous baliff wrongly chastized me for using the phone when the judge was not on the bench. This insignificant little man - drunk with the power of suddenly being a baliff - made such a big deal about me emailing the victim's family on my phone that the defendant and his family decided it must be okay to join in and mock me for my chastizement. The stupid little man drunk with power didn't seem to realize that it was his responsibility to get the family under control despite the fact that he caused the problem.
Would you like to know what all of this accomplished???
Well, this is a capital murder trial. We're asking for life NOT death. Even so, I've been trying to convince my boss to give the jury the option of the lesser included offense of murder. Not anymore. He clearly is as mean as our case shows because he's raised a mean family. It will probably be better for his kids and grandkids if he does a little time to learn a little humility. Maybe he will even understand what it means to be afraid of other people like his 29 year old female victim was afraid of him when she died.
As far as the small man who caused the problem... well, he'll be taking a class now to learn how to be a baliff. He was also replaced for today and tomorrow by someone who immediately let the family know that outbursts will get them kicked out of court for the duration of the trial. Oh! And the new baliff let me email the victim's family on my phone when the judge was not on the bench. It's amazing what playing the upset wide-eyed woman will get you in the south.
Would anyone else like to mess with me???
Thursday, April 7, 2011
Wednesday, April 6, 2011
Drunkard in the Courtroom
By Ann
Endlessly grueling hours of studying contract law, property law, constitutional law, business law, statute interpretation, legal research and writing, and advocacy skills in law school proved to be a colossal waste of time when it came time to actually practice law. I didn’t know it at the time and I naively believed that my J.D. was going to save me from the major I had taken up in college. I majored in psychology and lived in a major city. In between classes, I would sit on a park bench reading and I would try to drown out the vocalized incoherent rants of the people pushing grocery carts filled with garbage and having conversations with invisible beings. Sometimes I would look at them and wonder; what is the point of having an imaginary friend who agitates you to the point where you are verbally arguing with them in public? Personally, I would have a very agreeable friend…but I digress.
Today I represented a man who was charged with public drunkenness. Before I met him, I looked at the file and wondered why the cops didn’t have anything better to do with their time. I mean this wasn’t a driving under the influence offense and so what if a man is drunk in public. I had quite the attitude as I traveled to court. In my head, I dressed the police officer in a burqa worn by the moral police in the Mideast and I played a game of imaginary wack a mole with the officer in place of the mole. My indignation lasted all of less than a second once I was confronted with the offender.
![]() |
| pic found at moderndrunkardmagazine.com |
We sat in a room and he was clearly drunk. I don’t mean under the influence. I don’t mean buzzed. I mean drunk. Mean and nasty and perverted and DRUNK. I couldn’t explain anything to him. I did tell him that I think he’s drunk but with the care and caution and artful skill that only a person who lived in a city, studied psychology, and who talked a drunk friend out of driving can do. He smelled so bad that I got a little lightheaded. And he wanted a hearing. And he wanted to testify.
Nothing in law school could have prepared me for this guy. There is no mention of the drunken weirdo in the Uniform Commercial Code. I don’t know what to do so I tell the judge we are ready to proceed and I hope that he smells the guy to spare me from having to take any action.
The judge takes the bench. He stops writing and asks the Officer- Officer have you been drinking? No, your honor.
Counsel, have you been drinking? I can’t find my voice, where the heck did it go? Finally, I push through my angst which is paralyzing me as bad as a waking dream and I mutter, “No, your honor.” And I try to stifle a laugh as the judge asks every person in the courtroom if they have been drinking.
Ultimately, my client was put in jail to dry out before his hearing. But before he was taken away, he stared at me, giggled, and rubbed his privates.
Good thing I got this J.D. - it sure insulated me in a profession where I don’t have to deal with crazy.
Good thing.
Tuesday, April 5, 2011
Bullies bullies everywhere!
By Shannon
You know that kid who used to bully you on the playground - often for no reason at all. Remember how your parents (if they were like mine) would tell you to "just ignore them and they'll go away?" Remember how that only worked for a day or two if it worked at all? I'm sure you parents are picturing the kid who's mean to your child. I bet you never knew it was possible for a grown person to hate an 8 year old that much until that 8 year old started bullying your kid.
We had a neighborhood bully - I'll call him Manny for the purposes of this post. We were in the same grade. One day Manny and his best friend Cretin decided to steal a little girl's poster board in the school yard and my little sister who was in 1st grade bravely interceded. The friend she was defending turned tail and ran. When I came out of 5th grade that day, one of them had my sister with her arms behind her back and a large group of 5th grade boys surrounding her. They kept us there for what seemed like hours, though I'm sure that less than a half hour passed before my father came looking for us. (We walked to and from school back then.) A teacher saw what was going on and offered no help. In fact, she turned her back and went inside. Finally we saw my father and tried to run to him. This next part happened in slow motion. My father seemed to grow about 3 feet taller while one boy tripped my sister to my right and caused her to scrape both knees. When my father reached us we each grabbed onto one of his legs as he grabbed Manny's shirt collar in his left and and Cretin's shirt collar in his right and lifted them above his head. I don't remember what he said, but I know that when he put them down all those boys scattered like roaches. Later my father went to talk to Manny's father. (We didn't sue bullies back then.) I don't know what happened at that "talk" but I do know that Manny's family left the neighborhood when school ended that year and I never had problems with Cretin again.
I've thought about Manny over the years. I'm sure if I remembered his last name I could find him in the prisoner database for the Department of Corrections. Then it dawned on me... if bullies don't end up dead or in jail, do you know where they end up?
That's right. Judges often bully for no reason other than that they can. They belittle you and insult you ESPECIALLY if you accidentally show that you are smarter than they are. I never realized that judges are just bullies who make six-figures a year until last night when I was telling Ann about a particularly mean thing a judge did to me in court. She commiserated and then said, "Judges are just bullies!" Yes, my friend, they can be and are too often. Power corrupts.
You know that kid who used to bully you on the playground - often for no reason at all. Remember how your parents (if they were like mine) would tell you to "just ignore them and they'll go away?" Remember how that only worked for a day or two if it worked at all? I'm sure you parents are picturing the kid who's mean to your child. I bet you never knew it was possible for a grown person to hate an 8 year old that much until that 8 year old started bullying your kid.
We had a neighborhood bully - I'll call him Manny for the purposes of this post. We were in the same grade. One day Manny and his best friend Cretin decided to steal a little girl's poster board in the school yard and my little sister who was in 1st grade bravely interceded. The friend she was defending turned tail and ran. When I came out of 5th grade that day, one of them had my sister with her arms behind her back and a large group of 5th grade boys surrounding her. They kept us there for what seemed like hours, though I'm sure that less than a half hour passed before my father came looking for us. (We walked to and from school back then.) A teacher saw what was going on and offered no help. In fact, she turned her back and went inside. Finally we saw my father and tried to run to him. This next part happened in slow motion. My father seemed to grow about 3 feet taller while one boy tripped my sister to my right and caused her to scrape both knees. When my father reached us we each grabbed onto one of his legs as he grabbed Manny's shirt collar in his left and and Cretin's shirt collar in his right and lifted them above his head. I don't remember what he said, but I know that when he put them down all those boys scattered like roaches. Later my father went to talk to Manny's father. (We didn't sue bullies back then.) I don't know what happened at that "talk" but I do know that Manny's family left the neighborhood when school ended that year and I never had problems with Cretin again.
I've thought about Manny over the years. I'm sure if I remembered his last name I could find him in the prisoner database for the Department of Corrections. Then it dawned on me... if bullies don't end up dead or in jail, do you know where they end up?
AS A JUDGE ON THE BENCH
That's right. Judges often bully for no reason other than that they can. They belittle you and insult you ESPECIALLY if you accidentally show that you are smarter than they are. I never realized that judges are just bullies who make six-figures a year until last night when I was telling Ann about a particularly mean thing a judge did to me in court. She commiserated and then said, "Judges are just bullies!" Yes, my friend, they can be and are too often. Power corrupts.
Monday, April 4, 2011
Meet Inmate Number
By Ann

For a spring morning, it is unusually cold. I stand shivering and ring the rusted buzzer clinging to the concrete wall and wait for the faceless voice to ask me what is my business here. He buzzes me in and I struggle with the heavy, unwelcoming door. Even though I feel a burst of warm air, it is less comforting than the freedom of the cold air still clinging to my back. I am here for a conference with one of my incarcerated clients. I have some bad news like I do most days and I have to give this information to a person who is residing in a living, institutional hell.
As I step through the threshold, all of my senses are immediately assaulted.
I can smell sweat, urine, bad breath, and a staleness that can only be experienced and comprehended through the hoarding of human beings in a confined space.
I see my client. I see his dirty canvas jumpsuit and his dirty used canvas sneakers without any shoelaces.
I hear the cries of inmates housed like dogs and the barking commands of the faceless correctional officers over the intercom.
I can feel the eyes of the prison always watching me whether it be in person or through the video cameras mounted all over the place.
As I stand there, I am reminded of a conversation that I overheard between two members of the general public. One was complaining that inmates have it so good on our tax dollars. The other emphatically lamented that they have it better than most, what with 3 meals a day and a roof over their head. I so wished they could be here with me.
The Experience of an Inmate with a Number
An inmate comes into the prison and gets a number. Inmate number replaces his or her name. Inmate number is then given a cell. The cell is smaller than most walk in closets. In this cell, inmate number shares close quarters with another person. This person may smell. This person may be a sociopath. This person may be a violent gang member. This person may have a communicable disease. This person may have nothing in common with inmate number. But inmate number will spend much time with this person and if this person is lactose intolerant- inmate number will know. This is because the toilet is in the middle of the cell without doors right next to the sink where inmate number will brush their teeth.
Inmate number will get to work in prison and get paid for it. Inmate number earns an average of $.16 an hour. This is not even enough to buy a toothbrush at the end of the day. And without money, inmate number will not be given toiletries, snacks, or soap.
Inmate number will wear the prison issued clothes. The dirty canvas robe can never be cleaned enough. Inmate number will get a pair of shoes that have holes in them. Inmate number will get underwear and socks that are stained and soiled from the previous inmate number. But inmate number cannot opt out of wearing the undergarments.
Inmate number will have to avoid fights, gangs, drugs, sexual predators, and write ups while being housed with other inmates. Inmate number will be susceptible to sickness, staph infections, and other institutional maladies. Inmate number will have to fight the odds.
So far all of those people in the dark who complain that inmates have too many rights, or that they have it so good in prison, I invite you to share a cell with inmate number.
Cancel your family vacation and let everyone experience this fun. Who knows, as an added bonus, you or your family members may get raped, beat up, or come home with MRSA.
The possibilities are endless.
Friday, April 1, 2011
"I need to know"
By Shannon
My first capital murder trial begins on Monday. This is a major milestone in an attorney's life. I've agonized a bit over the case here and here and here with you. Later this month we should have a verdict very near the 17th anniversary of the murders of this man and this woman. Today I met with the female victim's best friend and roommate. It has been almost 17 years since she last heard the victim's voice or saw her face, but her grief has not diminished. As soon as we began talking about the victim, she began tearing up. She pulled it together and did a great job. She will be a fantastic witness. I let her hold her best friend's 17 year old day planner and journal. I watched as she caressed both without even realizing it as she told me about her friend. As soon as I handed her the day planner, she smelled it hoping I guess to feel her friend near her one more time. I tried to prep her for trial, but she had only one thing on her mind.
"What happened to her?" she asked me.
I cannot explain or express the deep affinity I felt for this woman who still mourns her friend. I gave her a glossed-over cliff notes version.
"But what happened?" she asked when I was done.
I must have looked confused because she began to explain.
"For 17 years people have said that I don't need to know - that knowing could cause nightmares. I've had nightmares for 17 years! I kept waiting for her to come back. I took care of her pets and paid what bills of hers I could. I kept waiting, but..." There was a long pause as the tears welled up in her eyes. "I need to know. I need to know exactly what happened."
I told the story again with more details this time. "She didn't suffer," I promised at the end.
"Now I know," she said with gratitude.
"Does that help you?" I asked truly concerned for her emotional well-being.
"Yes. I always dreamed she'd been tied up and tortured..."
"NO!" I interrupted.
"...or raped..."
"NO!"
"...or held against her will..."
"NO!"
The woman paused. I could see the 33 year old in the 50 year old who sat before me. I could also see one last question brewing. I waited to see if she could muster the courage to get it out. Finally she did.
"Was she afraid?" she asked.
"She didn't have time to be," I lied.
She didn't need to know.
My first capital murder trial begins on Monday. This is a major milestone in an attorney's life. I've agonized a bit over the case here and here and here with you. Later this month we should have a verdict very near the 17th anniversary of the murders of this man and this woman. Today I met with the female victim's best friend and roommate. It has been almost 17 years since she last heard the victim's voice or saw her face, but her grief has not diminished. As soon as we began talking about the victim, she began tearing up. She pulled it together and did a great job. She will be a fantastic witness. I let her hold her best friend's 17 year old day planner and journal. I watched as she caressed both without even realizing it as she told me about her friend. As soon as I handed her the day planner, she smelled it hoping I guess to feel her friend near her one more time. I tried to prep her for trial, but she had only one thing on her mind.
"What happened to her?" she asked me.
I cannot explain or express the deep affinity I felt for this woman who still mourns her friend. I gave her a glossed-over cliff notes version.
"But what happened?" she asked when I was done.
I must have looked confused because she began to explain.
"For 17 years people have said that I don't need to know - that knowing could cause nightmares. I've had nightmares for 17 years! I kept waiting for her to come back. I took care of her pets and paid what bills of hers I could. I kept waiting, but..." There was a long pause as the tears welled up in her eyes. "I need to know. I need to know exactly what happened."
I told the story again with more details this time. "She didn't suffer," I promised at the end.
"Now I know," she said with gratitude.
"Does that help you?" I asked truly concerned for her emotional well-being.
"Yes. I always dreamed she'd been tied up and tortured..."
"NO!" I interrupted.
"...or raped..."
"NO!"
"...or held against her will..."
"NO!"
The woman paused. I could see the 33 year old in the 50 year old who sat before me. I could also see one last question brewing. I waited to see if she could muster the courage to get it out. Finally she did.
"Was she afraid?" she asked.
"She didn't have time to be," I lied.
She didn't need to know.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

